Uncategorized | February 08, 2004
Reviewing the greats
I’m finishing my review of Toni Morrison’s new novel, Love, for The Missouri Review, and throughout the process the question of necessity has dogged me–what purpose do reviews of new work by well-established authors serve? Morrison’s novels proliferate in college classes, not only in literature, but also in history, sociology, and African-American studies, among others. Plus, she’s been publicly canonized by Oprah Winfrey. As most reviews of her novel point out, her career exists in the rare space of critical respect and public recognition; she’s won the Nobel Prize for Literature and appeared on the cover of Time magazine. I’ve approached reviewing the novel as both an appraisal of an individual aesthetic work and part of a larger context of her authorial record. For most readers out there, I’m not sure what’s more important. Is my job simply to announce a new novel by a great author? Do I rank it among what of her work is necessary to read and what is not?
An interesting complication of this idea is the reissue: John Updike’s The Early Stories was recently published, as was Richard Bausch’s The Stories of Richard Bausch. The former collects Updike’s early work, while the latter collects all of Bausch’s short fiction. The critical line on both fat volumes is that they establish the writers as American masters of the short story. I agree completely; Updike and Bausch both handle interiors deftly and in distinct ways. But reviews of their collections seem only to be canonizing them with little detail about what makes their work really vital. If I reviewed them, though, I’d probably find myself echoing the praise of them as authors and as figures, but I find myself wanting more. I’m not looking for dissent about their greatness (though I suspect that could be valuable if done well), but I want reviewers to contextualize their work more, to do more than reiterate their greatness to readers who already recognize that greatness.
SEE THE ISSUE
SUGGESTED CONTENT

Poem of the Week
Feb 06 2023
“The Horse That Threw Me” by Alexandra Teague
This week’s Poem of the Week is “The Horse That Threw Me” by Alexandra Teague. Alexandra Teague is the author of three books of poetry—Or What We’ll Call Desire (Persea,… read more

Poem of the Week
Jan 30 2023
Excerpt from “Epistle” by Robert Laidler
This week’s Poem of the Week is excerpted from “Epistle” by Robert Laidler. Robert Laidler, Assistant Professor of Teaching in the Wayne State Department of English, is the author of… read more

Poem of the Week
Jan 23 2023
“Stone Fruit” by Rebecca Foust
This week’s Poem of the Week is “Stone Fruit” by Rebecca Foust. Rebecca Foust’s fourth full-length book ONLY (Four Way Books 2022) received a starred review from Publisher’s Weekly. Recognitions… read more